• HS Baseball 4/23: Kingsford 6, Marquette 2
  • HS Baseball 4/23: Norway 15, North Central 0
  • HS Softball 4/23: Gladstone 10, Menominee 0
  • HS Softball 4/23: Negaunee 5, Escanaba 1
  • HS Softball 4/23: Calumet 15, Kingsford 3
  • HS Baseball 4/23: Negaunee 3, Hancock 2
  • HS Softball 4/23: Norway 9, North Dickinson 5
  • HS Softball 4/23: Sault Ste. Marie 20, Marquette 10
5910 articles
Wednesday April 24, 2024
U.P. Senator Calls Football Cancellation 'Ridiculous'


Upper Peninsula State Senator Ed McBroom calls the cancellation of the high school and college football seasons in Michigan “ridiculous” and says that the decisions will hurt kids, young adults, and entire communities.

“It’s bunk,” McBroom (R-Norway) told RRN News Tuesday afternoon. “Plain and simple bunk! We are now highlighting just how ridiculous this has gotten. Whether it’s ridiculous in the sense in how you feel about the virus itself, or ridiculous in the fear of liability, we have completely let fear take over for rationality at this point.”

The Michigan High School Athletic Association, acting on Governor Gretchen Whitmer’s request to not play football this fall, pulled the plug on the season last week. That decision came after many teams had already begun practicing.

McBroom, a dairy farmer from rural Dickinson County, says that he was not a big sports guy when he was young. He was more into music and forensics as a teen. But McBroom recognizes how it’s important for kids, and McBroom says that cancelling football will do nothing to stop the virus.

“To honestly think that somehow by disbanding football for the year, and making kids wear masks in the classroom, we are making them safer, because they’re not going to be hanging out with each other after hours?” McBroom said. “They’re not going to be hanging out with each other on weekends with no masks on? This is so incredibly shortsighted and ludicrous.”

And McBroom was just getting started.

“Who are these people who thought that this was somehow going to make kids and communities safer? I would argue that having a football season, and having a coach tell his team: ‘look, I can’t afford to have any one of you getting this virus, and getting sick. You need to wear a mask, you need to stay safe, you need to not hang out with kids from other schools’. That would have been more structurally safe than to just say, well, sorry, go home and do whatever you want for all evening. I mean, it’s just ridiculous.”

McBroom, who has also been a teacher, says the lack of a football season will be felt on the academic side of things.

“For some kids, the opportunity to play sports is that motivation to do better in those academic classes,” McBroom said. “We’re  taking away some things that for some kids are the motivation to get up and be at school today! We’re hurting them, and we didn’t even try to create a creative solution to the problem. It’s so devastating to those students and to their opportunity and to their motivation for their academics. And it’s hurtful to our communities.”

Whitmer has consistently said that playing football is not safe, and could easily spread the virus because of the "intimate" close contact nature of the sport.

But McBroom says some solutions could have included schools playing against each other within a 100-mile radius, or within the governor’s regions (the U.P. is Region Eight).

“We could have done something unique. We could have kept sports alive. Instead, we just cancel it, and pretend that it’s making the situation better. It’s so frustrating.”

For his part, MHSAA Director Mark Uyl said it was a difficult decision to cancel the football season and try again next spring, as he is a football parent himself.

“At the end of the day, we did everything we could to find a path forward for football this fall,” Uyl said. “But while continuing to connect with the Governor’s office, state health department officials, our member schools’ personnel and the Council, there is just too much uncertainty and too many unknowns to play football this fall."

Meanwhile, across the border in Wisconsin, literally five miles away from Iron Mountain-Kingsford, the Niagara-Goodman-Pembine "Northern Elite" Predators announced their football season will open on Sept. 25 with a game against Crandon.

Another neighboring state, Indiana, had a full slate of football games last weekend, and Ohio and Pennsylvania are also moving forward. A number of other states have either started, or will soon start, their football seasons as well.

Here in Michigan, a Facebook group has been gaining steam since the MHSAA pulled the plug on the season with the hashtag “Let Michigan High School Football Play”.

As of Tuesday afternoon, the group, started by a football mom at downstate Milan High School, had 16,323 members. Posts on the page have drawn thousands of shares and comments, many of which echoed McBroom’s sentiments.U.P.

The group is planning a rally at the state capitol this Friday at 4:00 ET and is encouraging players, coaches, and others from around Michigan to be there. The group is also speaking up on behalf of other high school sports teams which may also be cancelled in the coming months.

Wilson Hired New Eskymo Varsity Football Coach
Monday January 18, 2021
ROLLIN' RAAB: Transfer Helps Jets Win State Title
Saturday January 16, 2021
Sunday January 10, 2021
WORTH THE WAIT: Jets Headed To State Finals
Saturday January 9, 2021
END OF THE LINE: Iron Mtn. Loses Heartbreaker
Saturday January 9, 2021
Escanaba Eskymos Football Coach Howes Resigning
Wednesday December 23, 2020
HS Football, Volleyball To Resume; Others Waiting
Friday December 18, 2020
Sportswriters Release 2020 All-U.P. Football Teams
Thursday December 17, 2020
MHSAA Council Takes No Action; Rally Set Friday
Wednesday December 9, 2020
CRUSHED: Jets Football Team Reacts To Shutdown
Monday December 7, 2020
MHSAA 'Disappointed' With Shutdown Extension
Monday December 7, 2020
MHSAA Releases Plan For Playoffs; Winter Sports
Wednesday November 18, 2020
Escanaba's Maki To Play Football At Michigan Tech
Wednesday November 18, 2020
MHSAA Halts Tournaments Following State Order
Sunday November 15, 2020
ON TO THE FINAL FOUR: Jets Roll Over Trojans
Friday November 13, 2020
STATEMENT MADE: Jets Fly To Playoff Win, 52-8
Sunday November 8, 2020
CRUISE CONTROL: NCA Jets Smack Eagles, 74-6
Sunday November 1, 2020
Escanaba Football Season Ends With Playoff Loss
Saturday October 31, 2020
ONE UP, ONE DOWN: Redmen Blast Puffer, 38-0
Saturday October 31, 2020
Negaunee Grinds Past Gladstone In Playoff Opener
Friday October 30, 2020
SURVIVE & ADVANCE: Rockets Rally; Beat 'Dogs
Thursday October 29, 2020
Pickford vs Stephenson Football Playoff Cancelled
Monday October 26, 2020
Jets Soar Past Stephenson To End Regular Season
Saturday October 24, 2020
DELTA COUNTY RIVALRY: Eskymos Rally, 20-12
Friday October 23, 2020
NCA Passes Road Test With Win Over Lake Linden
Saturday October 17, 2020
Gladstone Braves Have Rough Night In Menominee
Friday October 16, 2020
Esky Football Returns With JV Win Over Redmen
Thursday October 15, 2020
BATTLE OF UNBEATENS: Mustangs Stop Eagles
Saturday October 10, 2020
Braves Can't Overcome Mistakes, Lose Wild Game
Friday October 9, 2020
Kingsford JV's Top Gladstone; Rapid Varsity Wins
Thursday October 8, 2020
ROAD WARRIORS: Kelly, Potier (X2) Lead Braves
Friday October 2, 2020
Gladstone JV Football Team Powers Past Soo 24-6
Thursday October 1, 2020
Escanaba Football Team Rallies To Save Its Season
Tuesday September 29, 2020
Gov. Whitmer Won't Reconsider Athlete Mask Rule
Tuesday September 29, 2020
MHSAA Announces Changes For Football Playoffs
Monday September 28, 2020
North Central Dominates In Homecoming Victory
Saturday September 26, 2020
HAPPY IN HAPPY ROCK: Braves Football Is Back
Friday September 25, 2020
Westwood Tops Manistique In Season-Opener 44-0
Friday September 25, 2020
BOYS ARE BACK: North Central Rolls In Opener
Friday September 18, 2020
Gladstone vs Marquette Football Game Cancelled
Tuesday September 15, 2020
MHSAA: 'Can't Modify, Ignore' Whitmer Mask Rule
Friday September 11, 2020
Whitmer Orders Masks During High School Sports
Wednesday September 9, 2020
GAME ON! MHSAA Reinstates HS Football Season
Thursday September 3, 2020
Governor's Decision On High School Sports 'Soon'
Wednesday September 2, 2020
LET US PLAY!! Broncos, Jets Rally To Save Season
Friday August 28, 2020
Michigan High School Football Season Cancelled
Friday August 14, 2020
U.P. High School Football Programs Get Donations
Tuesday August 11, 2020