• HS Baseball 4/23: Kingsford 6, Marquette 2
  • HS Baseball 4/23: Norway 15, North Central 0
  • HS Softball 4/23: Gladstone 10, Menominee 0
  • HS Softball 4/23: Negaunee 5, Escanaba 1
  • HS Softball 4/23: Calumet 15, Kingsford 3
  • HS Baseball 4/23: Negaunee 3, Hancock 2
  • HS Softball 4/23: Norway 9, North Dickinson 5
  • HS Softball 4/23: Sault Ste. Marie 20, Marquette 10
5910 articles
Wednesday April 24, 2024
Group Filing Lawsuit In Bid To Start Contact Sports

Click the AUDIO buttons to hear the interview with McElvany, as well as Gov. Whitmer's comments on contact sports.

ESCANABA---
A group that supports the start of Michigan's high school contact sports seasons is taking legal action against Gov. Gretchen Whitmer and the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services, who have put sports like basketball, hockey, wrestling, and competitive cheer on hold since mid-November.

The group of parents, students, coaches, and others called "Let Us Play" was speargeaded by Monroe business owner and high school sports mom, Jayme McElvany, says that they've pleaded with the MDHHS to let sports begin as had been planned on Feb. 1. But when the state did not reverse its orders, McElvaney says legal action was the only option.

"If we don't do it now, it's now or never for these kids," McElvany told RRN Sports Monday night. "It's now or never for their sports, now or never for their mental health to even be able to recover from this, because they're giving up. The kids are giving up all hope."

And so they will ask a Michigan District Court judge to grant an emergency injunction, which would allow the Michigan High School Athletic Association to begin its seasons Feb. 1.

Whitmer, earlier on Monday, said contact sports are too risky to be held right now, especially with the new "variant" of the virus being detected in downstate Washtenaw County. That variant is believed to be more contagious than the strain that's been around since last March.

“It’s important that we keep watching the numbers,” Whitmer said. “I understand the concerns that parents and athletes have and their desire to reengage. But I also point to some of the events that happened in the last couple of days. We are seeing this variant growing around Washtenaw County and around the University of Michigan campus. Our job is to curtail the spread of this new variant in Michigan."

"Whether it is contact sports, or bumping up that (capacity) limit for in-person dining, these are actions that will increase contacts and could create spread."

McElvany says that other states have proven that sports can be done safely, and she's confident that the Michigan High School Athletic Association has a good plan in place.

"We have so much data now because of our fall seasons," McElvany said. "They (MDHHS) did it themselves with the pilot (testing) project. They don't like their own data that showed 99.98 percent negative. So they keep moving the goalposts, they keep changing it. I don't care if there's 50 variants. We have to figure out how to move forward in life."

For his part, MHSAA Director Mark Uyl, remains extremely frustrated. He says the organization thought after the current "pause" expired on Jan. 31, that they would be able to move forward with those sports. But he says they were blindsided by the extension of that shutdown through Feb. 21, saying that the MHSAA was not told any reasons why.

On Monday, Uyl was still unhappy.

“We are unable to provide specific plans yet as we are still evaluating the best options for delivering a memorable experience for 60,000 athletes involved in Winter contact sports," Uyl said. "We will continue asking questions and advocating for all of our schools and athletes as we work toward building our next plans for seasons in basketball, competitive cheer, ice hockey and wrestling. We will be ready with specific timelines as soon as MDHHS clears contact sports to begin full activity."

Uyl says that when protocols are in place, sports can, and have been, done safely. He says that the benefits to kids are more than just getting on the court or ice, but also are important to mental health and give teens an incentive to stay out of trouble.

MDHHS, however, in a statement on Monday, said that there were indeed 42 outbreaks associated with contact sports (high school, college, and other combined) back in the fall. An outbreak can be as little as two positive tests that are connected to a single source.

"Outbreaks of this magnitude have the potential to affect not just a sports team, but the community in which the players and coaches reside as well," MDHHS spokesman Lynn Suffin told Mlive.com on Monday. "Sports that require frequent closeness between players make it more difficult to prevent disease transmission, compared to sports where players are not as close to each other. The risk of COVID-19 transmission is increased by the number of individuals a player physically interacts with, as well as the intensity and duration of that interaction."

McElvany says that there's more at stake than just the virus.

"There's no such thing as sitting back and watching children across the country commit suicide," she said. "We lost two more athletes this week to suicide. We can't just sit back and do nothing."

And so McElvany is organizing a rally this Saturday in Lansing, after holding two similiar rallies in August and November to advocate for football, volleyball, and swimming. Those sports were able to finish their seasons this month as part of the aforementioned pilot project where students were tested for the coronavirus three times per week.

McElvany says the Facebook group that she has run since August now has more than 27,000 members. That includes an increase of nearly 8,000 members in the past three days.

"There's so many parents and athletes ready to sign affidavits for the lawsuit that I just can't even keep up with it," she said. "We have athletic directors reaching out like crazy. We have coaches. I'd say the response for this rally is quadruple from the other rallies. This rally is going to be incredible."

Detroit Public School Superitendent Dr. Nikolai Vitti sent the governor a letter on Monday, which he also released to the media. Vitti said that if schools are open to in-person learning, then sports should be allowed to continue.

“To be direct, winter ‘contact’ sports need to start,” Vitti wrote.“Most of us supported the suspension of winter sports in November and December, but that delay now is unnecessary and causing undue harm to our student-athletes. Our families have analyzed the risk of playing and they want to play. Let the Michigan High School Athletic Association handle sports from this point forward."

There were also calls from some state representatives to allow contact sports.

"Parents and coaches are understandably concerned for their kids,” said Rep. Andrew Fink (R-Hillsdale), who is also a father of five. “Sports provide our young people with confidence and structure while teaching them important life lessons like teamwork and perseverance.”

“Contact sports have not been shown to be a significant vehicle for spreading the virus,” said Rep. Bradley Slagh (R-Zeeland). “Schools have already adopted cleaning and tracking procedures, further reducing the likelihood of the virus being spread.”

McElvany says the rally will be held at 12:00 noon this Saturday at the state capitol, and is a combined effort with Coopersville High School basketball player Ethan Coadey. Coadey was organizing his own rally but McElvaney reached out to combine the rallies.

Uyl says that the MHSAA is ready to proceed when given the opportunity.

“We have said from the start of the 2019-20 school year that we would do everything possible to have three seasons, and play all three to completion," Uyl said. "Our strong advocacy for all sports and seasons – and especially Winter sports – continues every day.”

Whitmer, meanwhile, argues that the restrictions have worked.

"We are the envy of other states," she said Monday. "Our numbers are going down, and we're in a stronger position.We've got to not let our guard down."

The current state order banning contact sports runs through Feb. 21. Non contact sports, including bowling, gymastics, skiing, and swimming, can resume Feb. 1. All winter sports are allowed to practice right now, with no contact allowed.






Choose team:
No schedule entries



Hughes Resigns After Eight Years As Eskymo Coach
Tuesday August 31, 2021
Kaptain Kolich Kleans Up At Esky Hockey Awards
Wednesday May 5, 2021
Marquette Dominates Escanaba To Take Regional
Saturday March 20, 2021
LA' VICTORY! Eskymos Stop Kingsford In Opener
Thursday March 18, 2021
FIVE IN A ROW: Eskymos Overwhelm Blue Devils
Friday March 12, 2021
LaMarch, Mylander Help Eskymos Hold Off Jeffers
Wednesday March 10, 2021
LET'S PLAY TWO: Esky Hockey Sweeps Negaunee
Saturday March 6, 2021
Bourdeau Brothers Help Eskymos Beat Jeffers, 3-1
Friday March 5, 2021
Escanaba Hockey Team Battles; Loses In Hancock
Friday February 19, 2021
FIRST VICTORY: Escanaba 'Bounces' Past Soo, 5-4
Wednesday February 17, 2021
BACK ON THE ICE: Hancock Beats Escanaba, 9-3
Monday February 8, 2021
Escanaba HS Hockey Team 'Grateful' To Get Season
Thursday February 4, 2021
GAME ON: Whitmer Reverses HS Sports Shutdown
Thursday February 4, 2021
Lawsuit Filed Seeking Start Of Youth Winter Sports
Tuesday February 2, 2021
Mich. Senate Votes Unanimously To Support Sports
Thursday January 28, 2021
U.P. Lawmakers Urge Whitmer: 'Let The Kids Play'
Wednesday January 27, 2021